• Markets
  • Crypto
  • Web3
  • Culture
  • Opinion
  • Politics
Subscribe
  • Login
  • Register
No Result
View All Result
  • Markets
  • Crypto
  • Web3
  • Culture
  • Opinion
  • Politics
No Result
View All Result
No Result
View All Result

Taproot Based Bitcoin NFTs Spark Controversy

30/01/2023 12:00
No comments
Bitcoin NFTs, Jan 2023

Bitcoin NFTs, Jan 2023

Bitcoin now has NFTs and they’re completely on-chain and they can be as much as 4MB of data, allowing for short videos and even the Satoshi whitepaper to be published on the blockchain.

This may allow the crypto to compete with ethereum, which dominates on NFTs and by far, but some are not happy.

Adam Back, the CEO of Blockstream which hires many bitcoin developers, went as far as to call for censorship.

“It’s also fair game for miners to censor the crap as a form of discouragement,” Back said in a now deleted tweet.

“I retracted/deleted that as it was stupid and getting misinterpreted,” he said, arguing instead that “we can educate and encourage developers who care about bitcoin’s use-case to either not do that, or do it in a prunable space-efficient eg time-stamp way.”

The current way done by Ordinals is to store the data on the part of the transaction that is meant to hold segregated witnesses.

That provides a 75% discount on transaction fees to other data, making the minting of these NFTs very cheap, costing about $20 when they would cost as much as $140 in ethereum.

The data is also prunable in as far as they don’t have to be stored on UTXO – the transactions memory part of a node – although a synchronizing node has to download them.

The NFT in addition is a satoshi. Their serial number is used to differentiate them, allowing for the attribution of the data that was made possible by the Taproot upgrade in 2021.

This loophole was meant to potentially facilitate smart contracts on bitcoin, but is now being used for pictures of doge.

Bitcoin NFT, Jan 2023
Bitcoin NFT, Jan 2023

The NFT is a very long string of numbers and letters on-chain, with special software requires to translate it into an actual picture.

Ordinary transactions wouldn’t have the highlighted part, but modified software like Ordinal can input it.

The Ordinals website itself does not seem to have a marketplace, and as is usual with bitcoin projects, the site design leaves much to be desired as it looks very amateur.

But it lets you see the latest satoshi jpegs, with each paying miners for inclusion. Proponents therefore argue that this benefits the network as it adds to miner’s subsidy, but opponents argue that it is a very inefficient way of storing pictures.

Although considering these are immutable images, it is the most efficient way to store them for long term accessibility, with miners unlikely to censor as they’re paid fees.

Devs also might not change the feature because it is probably needed for Blockstream products, at least eventually.

So the very controversial Segwit upgrade has managed in the end to give dogecoin pictures a 75% network fee discount, while not quite achieving much else.

These pictures moreover have twice the storage available than ordinary transactions, 4MB rather than about 1.8MB, with bitcoin devs in the end so privileging a use case they don’t like.

Yet this can only add about 200GB of data a year, which can nonetheless be significant without a proper pruning mechanism.

Satoshi based assets however have not quite taken off. There have been many attempts, including Colored Coins, but bitcoin’s script language is too limited to really do much.

In addition the satoshi base of the asset, rather than its own token, also requires special software rather than just a bitcoin wallet. That may have contributed towards limited adoption.

The lack of a marketplace on Ordinals pretty much guarantees such lack of adoption for now, with uncertainties regarding what Blockstream might do making eth a far safer bet.

So a nice proof of concept, but arguably not a real NFT as it is not a token but a bitcoin dressed with jpegs, which for some makes it no different but does make it a lot more clunky.

Related Posts

Euro area inflation, March 2023

Inflation Falls More Than Expected in Europe

Two Faced Elizabeth Warren Allies with Banks Against Crypto, March 2023

Elizabeth Warren Allies with Banks

Bitcoin Up on Futures Expiry as Stocks Replace CME

Banks Keep Rolling Fed Loans

Load More
  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
US gov bitcoin holdings, March 2023

US Gov Becomes Top Holder of Bitcoin

CFTC

Bitcoin, Ethereum and Litecoin Are Commodities Says CFTC

Biden and other global leaders at the Summit for Democracy, March 2023

Is Dedollarization Happening?

The National Bureau of Economic Research

Goldman Sachs and JP Morgan Can’t Survive Bank Run Says NBER Paper, Fail Stress Test

CFTC

Bitcoin, Ethereum and Litecoin Are Commodities Says CFTC

Biden and other global leaders at the Summit for Democracy, March 2023

Is Dedollarization Happening?

Euro area inflation, March 2023

Inflation Falls More Than Expected in Europe

Two Faced Elizabeth Warren Allies with Banks Against Crypto, March 2023

Elizabeth Warren Allies with Banks

Coinbase on the day of Nasdaq Listing, April 2021

Bitcoin Up on Futures Expiry as Stocks Replace CME

Fed St. Louis HQ

Banks Keep Rolling Fed Loans

Comments

Latest News

  • Inflation Falls More Than Expected in Europe
  • Elizabeth Warren Allies with Banks
  • Bitcoin Up on Futures Expiry as Stocks Replace CME

About Trustnodes

Terms of Service

Privacy Policy

Our Ethics and Values

Trustnodes Newsletter

(You have to be a paid subscriber)

Trustnodes © 2017-2023. All Rights Fully Reserved. For any Enquiries contact@trustnodes.com RSS Feed

No Result
View All Result
  • Login
  • Sign Up
  • Cart
  • Markets
  • Crypto
  • Web3
  • Culture
  • Opinion
  • Politics

Trustnodes © 2017-2023. All Rights Fully Reserved. For any Enquiries contact@trustnodes.com RSS Feed

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Authenticate with MetaMask Loading...

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

*By registering into our website, you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.
All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.
Are you sure want to unlock this post?
Unlock left : 0
Are you sure want to cancel subscription?